| A Cool Mill (Bronze) | Score over 1,000,000 points as a band in any single song in Career or Quickplay |
| A New Challenge Awaits (Silver) | Complete 50 of the Career Challenges at Platinum or Diamond |
| Face to Face (Bronze) | Complete 25 online Pro Face-Off matches, win or lose |
| Fevered Pitch (Bronze) | 100% a song as a vocalist |
| Four of a Kind (Bronze) | Complete a song as 4 of the same instrument on any difficulty in Quickplay or Career |
| Glimmer (Bronze) | Earn 111 Stars in Career |
| Iced Out (Bronze) | Earn Diamond level on a Career Challenge |
| In the Moment (Bronze) | Successfully complete a Band Moment |
| Jack of All Trades (Bronze) | Complete at least one challenge for every instrument at Gold level or better |
| M.C. (Bronze) | Host an online Career game and play a song |
| My First Gig (Bronze) | Complete a Career gig on any difficulty |
| Nation's Star (Silver) | Complete 50% of the gigs in Career |
| Nice to Meet You (Silver) | Complete the gigs and unlock all of the celebrity characters |
| Picture Perfect (Bronze) | Streak through an entire song without missing a note on medium or harder difficulty |
| Platinum Blonde (Bronze) | Earn Platinum level on a Career Challange |
| Platinum Trophy (Platinum) | Earn all of the Bronze, Silver and Gold Trophies in Band Hero |
| Rise to Fame (Bronze) | Complete 25% of the gigs in Career |
| Road Most Travelled (Silver) | Unlock every venue |
| Secret Notes 1 (Bronze) | Hint: Jesse McCartney |
| Secret Notes 10 (Bronze) | Hint: Pat Benatar |
| Secret Notes 11 (Bronze) | Hint: No Doubt |
| Secret Notes 12 (Bronze) | Hint: Marvin Gaye |
| Secret Notes 13 (Bronze) | Hint: Spice Girls |
| Secret Notes 14 (Bronze) | Hint: Village People |
| Secret Notes 15 (Bronze) | Hint: Hilary Duff |
| Secret Notes 16 (Bronze) | Hint: Yellowcard |
| Secret Notes 17 (Bronze) | Hint: The All-American Rejects |
| Secret Notes 18 (Bronze) | Hint: Roy Orbison |
| Secret Notes 19 (Bronze) | Hint: Carl Douglas |
| Secret Notes 2 (Bronze) | Hint: Janet Jackson |
| Secret Notes 3 (Bronze) | Hint: The Rolling Stones |
| Secret Notes 4 (Bronze) | Hint: Lily Allen |
| Secret Notes 5 (Bronze) | Hint: Aly & AJ |
| Secret Notes 6 (Bronze) | Hint: Maroon 5 |
| Secret Notes 7 (Bronze) | Hint: David Bowie |
| Secret Notes 8 (Bronze) | Hint: Evanescence |
| Secret Notes 9 (Bronze) | Hint: Hinder |
| Shine (Silver) | Earn 555 Stars in Career |
| Sparkle (Silver) | Earn 333 Stars in Career |
| Star Light, Star Bright (Bronze) | Score over 10,000 points while in a single Star Power deployment in Career or Quickplay |
| Star Powered (Bronze) | Earn an 11x multiplier |
| Studio Time (Bronze) | Create a GH Studio song |
| Testing the Waters (Silver) | Play through every Band Hero song once |
| The Long Road Ahead (Gold) | Complete Career on any difficulty with any instrument |
| There's no 'I' in 'Band Hero' (Bronze) | Complete a song with 4 players without any members failing on expert in Career or Quickplay |
| Till Death Do Us Part (Bronze) | Play an online Do or Die game |
| Treasure Hunt (Gold) | Collect all of the Secret Notes |
| Welcome to Band Hero (Bronze) | Complete all of the tutorials |
| World Known (Silver) | Complete 75% of the gigs in Career |
