| Arkham Analyst (Bronze) | Solve 5% of riddler challenges |
| Baneful Payback (Silver) | Defeat Bane |
| Big Bang (Silver) | Complete story mode on Easy difficulty |
| Bigger Bang (Silver) | Complete story mode on Normal difficulty |
| Biggest Bang (Silver) | Complete story mode on Hard difficulty |
| Born Free (Bronze) | Escape from Intensive Treatment to the island surface |
| Breaking And Entering (Bronze) | Gain access to Arkham Mansion after it is locked down by the Joker |
| Catch! (Bronze) | Catch a Batarang (any play mode) |
| Conundrum Cracker (Bronze) | Solve 55% of riddler challenges |
| Crack The E Nigma (Silver) | Solve every riddle on the island |
| Crocodile Tears (Silver) | Venture into Killer Croc's lair and come out alive |
| Cryptic Investigator (Bronze) | Solve 10% of riddler challenges |
| Daydreamer (Bronze) | Survive the nightmare of the Scarecrow's fear gas |
| Double Trouble (Silver) | Defeat two Titan Henchmen at once |
| Flawless Freeflow Fighter (Bronze) | Complete one combat challenge without taking damage |
| Freakshow Rodeo (Bronze) | Ride Titan henchman and knock down 10 thugs (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Bronze (Bronze) | Achieve 8 medals on combat challenges |
| Freeflow Combo 10 (Bronze) | Complete a combo of 10 moves (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Combo 20 (Silver) | Complete a combo of 20 moves (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Combo 40 (Silver) | Complete a combo of 40 moves (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Combo 5 (Bronze) | Complete a combo of 5 moves (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Gold (Silver) | Achieve 24 medals on combat challenges |
| Freeflow Perfection (Silver) | Perform a perfect combo including all of Batman’s combat moves (any play mode) |
| Freeflow Silver (Bronze) | Achieve 16 medals on combat challenges |
| Invisible Predator (Bronze) | Complete one predator challenge by using only Silent Takedowns |
| Just What The Doctors Ordered (Bronze) | Save all the doctors in Medical |
| Lateral Thinker (Bronze) | Solve 25% of riddler challenges |
| Leave No Man Behind (Bronze) | Rescue the guards and henchman from the Joker toxin in Decontamination |
| Malpractice Needs More Practice (Bronze) | Survive the onslaught from the deformed Joker henchman |
| Mano-A-Mano (Silver) | Defeat Titan henchman without using Batarangs (any play mode) |
| Mental Athlete (Bronze) | Solve 70% of riddler challenges |
| Mystery Solver (Bronze) | Solve 40% of riddler challenges |
| Night Glider (Bronze) | Glide continuously for over 100m |
| Party Pooper (Bronze) | KO all the henchmen celebrating your arrival at the party |
| Perfect Knight (Gold) | 100% Complete |
| Platinum | Collect All Other Trophies |
| Poisoned Ivy (Silver) | Defeat the giant Titan Ivy plant |
| Predator Bronze (Bronze) | Achieve 8 medals on predator challenges |
| Predator Gold (Bronze) | Achieve 24 medals on predator challenges |
| Predator Silver (Bronze) | Achieve 16 medals on predator challenges |
| Recurring Nightmare (Bronze) | Face your biggest fears and keep your sanity |
| Resist The Fear (Silver) | Conquer the effects of the Scarecrow's fear gas |
| Riddle Resolver (Silver) | Solve 85% of Riddler challenges |
| Rope-a-dope-a-dope (Bronze) | String up one henchman and drop him to surprise a second (any play mode) |
| Shocking Rescue (Bronze) | Take down Zsasz in the Patient Pacification Chamber |
| Solitary Confinement (Silver) | Capture and lock up Harley Quinn |
| World’s Greatest Detective (Silver) | Spirit of Amadeus Arkham revealed |
| Zsasz Cut Down To Size (Bronze) | Save Dr. Young from being killed by Victor Zsasz |
