| 1st time out (Bronze) | Win an Online League match |
| A Man Down (silver) | Win a game when down one man |
| Bend it like a pro (Silver) | Score from a free kick in a match |
| Best of the Best (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Obtain your first gold Rated Manager |
| Bigger Venue (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Upgrade to a Silver Rated Stadium |
| Club god (Bronze) | Reach legendary status for your club |
| Club Tournament Mastery (Silver) | Ultimate Team:Win all gold Club Tournaments |
| Custom sixty four winner (Silver) | Win a Created Tournament that starts with sixty four teams |
| Director in the making (Bronze) | Upload a video to EA Sports^(TM) football world |
| Duo-Hedgeidecimal (Silver) | Enter a match with 20 people in a FIFA 09 Clubs Match |
| Eat my chip (Bronze) | Score by chipping the keeper in a match |
| FIFA Fair Play (Bronze) | Play 5 consecutive matches without getting any cards (bookings must be enabled in the settings) |
| Fling yourself at it (Bronze) | Score with a diving header in a match |
| Football Legend (platinum) | Unlock all other trophies (excluding additional content trophies) |
| Frequent flyer (Silver) | Win in every stadium |
| Giant Killer (Silver) | Beat a five star team with a half star team |
| Gimme five (Bronze) | Score five goals in the arena |
| Gold Packs (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Open First Gold Pack |
| Good head on your shoulders (Bronze) | Score with a header in a match |
| Hero (Bronze) | Save a penalty |
| Huge investment (Silver) | Buy a player in Manager Mode for 50 million of your chosen currency |
| Huge return (Gold) | Sell a player in Manager Mode for 50 million of your chosen currency |
| In off (Bronze) | Score off the woodwork in a match |
| Jonzo's lounge (Silver) | Score 2500 points and win 5 badges in a single Lounge Mode match |
| Judas (Bronze) | Beat your favourite team with their rival |
| Last Gasp Goal (Bronze) | Score in the 89th minute |
| Like on the training field (Bronze) | Score from a corner |
| Living legend (Silver) | Reach legendary status for your country |
| Manual labour (Bronze) | Win a match with fully manual settings (no assistance can be switched on) |
| On the spot (Bronze) | Score from a penalty in a match |
| On yer bike! (Silver) | Score with a bicycle kick |
| One goal a season (Bronze) | Score with a defender in a match |
| One star winners (Silver) | Win a Tournament that starts with sixteen teams, with a one star rated team. |
| Online Champion (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Win Gold Ultimate Team Trophy |
| Online Tournament Mastery (Silver) | Ultimate Team:Win All gold Online Tournaments |
| Optimus Chung (Bronze) | Win a game with adidas Live Season enabled |
| Pictures speak a thousand words (Bronze) | Upload 5 screenshots to EA Sports^(TM) football world |
| Provider (Bronze) | Perform a cross for a friend who scores from it. (Co-op) |
| Ranked Winner (Bronze) | Win a Ranked online match |
| Real world winner (Silver) | Win 5 Interactive League matches |
| Screamer! (Bronze) | Score from over 30 yards out in a match |
| Silver Packs (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Open first Silver Pack |
| Solid Gold (Silver) | Ultimate Team:Obtain 11 gold players |
| Sparkly clean (Bronze) | Keep a clean sheet |
| Spending spree (Silver) | Buy 50 players in your career in Manager Mode |
| The Collector (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Complete an 11 player team page in the collection |
| The Gipson Curse (Bronze) | Go into an online match after choosing your own arena player |
| The Kwong (Bronze) | Score a headed goal with the shortest created player |
| The ol' switcheroo (Bronze) | Successfully perfom a pass that switches the play from one flank to the other |
| The Peterson (Silver) | Play for over fifty hours |
| The Poon Sang (Bronze) | Win with a team of 11 created players in an unranked online match |
| The purist (Gold) | Complete a Manager Mode season without simming any games |
| The Venhola Ice (Bronze) | Win a FIFA 09 Clubs match with your club |
| Time you played a match? (Bronze) | Score twenty goals in the arena |
| What a Beauty! (Bronze) | Score on the volley in a match |
| Wing play (Bronze) | Score from a cross |
| World Champion (Bronze) | Ultimate Team:Win the Gold World Trophy |
