| 100% Clear (Platinum) | This is the platinum trophy and is unlocked automatically when all the trophies have been unlocked |
| Franchise - Complete 20 year Franchise with 5+ NBA Titles (Gold) | Complete 20 year Franchise with 5+ NBA Titles - any difficulty setting |
| Franchise - Win 3 NBA Finals (Silver) | Win 3 NBA titles - any years, any difficulty setting |
| Franchise - Win the NBA Finals (Bronze) | Win the NBA title - any year, any difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - 1-on-1 (Bronze) | Defeat opponent (Overall rating 85+) by 5 or more points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - 2-on-2 (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) by 5 or more points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - 3-on-3 (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) by 5 or more points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - 3-Point Shootout (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) by 5 or more points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - Blacktop Golf (Bronze) | Score 70 or less points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - Own The Court (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) by 8 or more points - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - PlayStation® Skills Challenge (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) by 3 or more seconds - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| Mini Games - Rabbit (Bronze) | Defeat opponents (Overall rating 85+) in a single game - Minimum All-Star difficulty setting |
| NBA Replay: The Season - Complete Entire Mode (Silver) | Complete Entire Mode - All Star difficulty setting |
| NBA Replay: The Season - Complete Entire Mode including all Extra Mile Goals (Gold) | Complete Entire Mode including all Extra Mle Goals - All Star difficulty setting |
| NBA Replay: The Season - Complete First Half of Mode (Bronze) | Complete First Half of Mode - All Star difficulty setting |
| Online 10 Game Winner (Silver) | Win 10 online games |
| Online 25 Game Winner (Gold) | Win 25 online games |
| Online 5 Game Winner (Bronze) | Win 5 online games |
| Player Progression - Advance 5 to 70+ (Bronze) | Advance 5 Progression Players to an Overall Rating of 70+ points for each player |
| Player Progression - Advance 5 to 80+ (Silver) | Advance 5 Progression Players to an Overall Rating of 80+ points for each player |
| Player Progression - Advance 5 to 90+ (Gold) | Advance 5 Progression Players to an Overall Rating of 90+ points for each player |
| Quick Play - Defeat 15 NBA Teams - All-Star (Silver) | Defeat 15 NBA Teams - min All-Star difficulty setting, 5 min + qtrs - no spotting points |
| Quick Play - Defeat 5 NBA Teams - All-Star (Bronze) | Defeat 5 NBA Teams - min All-Star difficulty setting, 5 min + qtrs - no spotting points |
| Quick Play - Defeat all 32 NBA Teams - All-Star (Gold) | Defeat 30 NBA Teams + All-Star Teams - min All-Star difficulty setting, 5 min + qtrs - no spotting points |
| The Life - All 3 Stories Completed (Gold) | Complete all 3 stories - Minimum Veteran difficulty, Complete all "Extra Mile" goals |
| The Life - Story #1 Completed (Silver) | Complete Story #1 - Minimum Veteran difficulty, Complete all "Extra Mile" goals |
| The Life - Story #2 Completed (Silver) | Complete Story #2 - Minimum Veteran difficulty, Complete all "Extra Mile" goals |
| The Life - Story #3 Completed (Silver) | Complete Story #3 - Minimum Veteran difficulty, Complete all "Extra Mile" goals |
