| 4th Quarter Comeback (Bronze) | Win an Exhib. or Dynasty Mode game when down by 14 to start the 4th quarter (min difficulty: Varsity) |
| Ball...Ball...Ball... (Bronze) | Jar the ball loose with a User-Controlled Hit Stick tackle. |
| Big Fish In A Small Pond (Bronze) | Become a 5-star Road to Glory prospect. |
| Big Man on Campus (Bronze) | In Road to Glory Mode, earn a spot on your team's All-Time leaderboard. |
| Big Time Player (Bronze) | Be the hero and win a game by taking the lead as time expires. |
| Bombs Away (Bronze) | Complete a pass for 50 or more yards in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Bustin' Loose (Bronze) | Break a run for 49 or more yards in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Can You Believe It? (Silver) | Return a missed field goal for a touchdown. Only valid in Exhibition or Dynasty Mode. |
| Closing Out Strong (Bronze) | Play and win a bowl game in single team Dynasty Mode or Road to Glory Mode. |
| Crash the Party (Bronze) | Earn an invite to a BCS game in Dynasty Mode with a team from a non-BCS conference. |
| Fill The Trophy Case (Gold) | Win all 34 bowl trophies (including National Championship) in Dynasty or Road to Glory modes. |
| Freshman Phenom (Bronze) | Win the Heisman Memorial Trophy? with a Freshman in Road to Glory or Dynasty Mode. |
| Getting In On The Fun (Bronze) | Take an interception back to the house in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Give Him 5 Minutes (Bronze) | Chew up the last 5 minutes of a game on a single drive to preserve the win. |
| Good Sport Award (Bronze) | Achieve a Sportsmanship Level of 10 in the Season Showdown competition. |
| Hear the Pin Drop (Bronze) | As the away team, get into the endzone in the first 30 seconds of the game. |
| Helping Your Own Cause (Bronze) | Scoop a fumble on defense and take it to the house in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| I'll Take My Trophy Please (Bronze) | Play and win a conference championship game in single team Dynasty Mode or Road to Glory Mode. |
| I'm Outstanding (Silver) | Win the Heisman Memorial Trophy? in single team Dynasty Mode or Road to Glory Mode. |
| Keep Them Guessing (Bronze) | Gain 200 rushing yards and 200 passing yards in the same game. |
| King of the Conference (Silver) | In Road to Glory Mode, earn a spot on your conference's All-Time leaderboard. |
| Locked and Loaded (Bronze) | With Player Lock on, return an interception for a TD. |
| Mad Skillz (Bronze) | Achieve a Skill Level of 10 in the Season Showdown competition. |
| Mr. February (Bronze) | Have the #1 ranked recruiting class in a season in single team Dynasty Mode. |
| National Champions! (Silver) | Play and win the BCS National Championship game in single team Dynasty Mode or Road to Glory Mode. |
| On Lockdown (Silver) | Hold the opposition to under 100 total yards in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| One for the History Books (Bronze) | Play a game that gets designated as an ESPN Instant Classic. |
| Pick-Free (Bronze) | Do not throw any interceptions in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| Platinum Trophy (Platinum) | Unlock every trophy |
| Protecting The House (Bronze) | Pitch a shutout by holding your opponent to zero points. Valid only in Exhibition or Dynasty Mode. |
| Put Two On The Board (Bronze) | Force a safety in Exhibition or Dynasty Mode. |
| Reach out and Crush Someone (Bronze) | Join or Host an Online Dynasty. |
| Red Zone Perfection (Bronze) | Complete an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game with a Red Zone Efficiency rating of 100% |
| Red Zone Shutout (Bronze) | Complete an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game without allowing a Touchdown from the Red Zone. |
| Running With The Ones (Bronze) | Become the Starter in Road to Glory Mode. |
| Russell High School Champ (Silver) | Play and win the Russell High School Championship Game in any state. |
| Set 'Em Up, Knock 'Em Down (Bronze) | Score a TD when running a play that is 100% setup. |
| Sip Some Texas Tea (Bronze) | Develop a new pipeline state in single team Dyansty Mode. |
| Strategery (Bronze) | Achieve a Strategy Level of 10 in the Season Showdown competition. |
| Taking Care of Business (Bronze) | Win an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game by 21 points or more. |
| That's How I Roll (Gold) | Achieve an Overall Level of 10 in the Season Showdown competition. |
| The Best of All-Time (Gold) | In Road to Glory Mode, earn a spot on the NCAA All-Time leaderboard. |
| Trifecta (Bronze) | Score a receiving, rushing, and passing touchdown with one player. |
| We Are Family (Bronze) | Win a game using only Family Play Controls in an Exhibition Mode game. |
| What Competition? (Bronze) | Win the 1st year SEC championship with a team moved from the Sun Belt in single team Dynasty Mode. |
| Will You Ever Learn? (Bronze) | Intercept 2 passes in an Exhibition or Dynasty Mode game. |
| You Got A Reciept For That? (Bronze) | Take a punt or kickoff back to the house for a touchdown. Valid only in Exhibition or Dynasty Mode. |
| You Gotta See This (Bronze) | Upload a Video or Photo Highlight. |
