| All Play (Bronze) | Complete and win an Online Versus Play ranked match with three or more guests on the same PS3 system |
| Assists King (Bronze) | Get 35 assists with your Be A Pro character |
| Battle for the Cup (Bronze) | Win a Battle for the Cup series with an Elite league team in a 7 game series against the CPU |
| Board Play (Bronze) | Pin a player using board play and gain possession of the puck |
| Break Away (Silver) | Score two break away goals in one match |
| Bronze Team (Bronze) | Be a member of an EA SPORTS Hockey League team that has won a Bronze medal |
| Call Me (Bronze) | Unlock 3 phones in Be a GM mode |
| Century Play (Gold) | Score a total of 100 goals in Online Versus Play ranked matches over your career |
| Don't Let Up (Silver) | Score four unanswered goals against the CPU or an online opponent in a ranked match |
| Dump It (Bronze) | Dump the puck outside the offensive blue line 10 times in one match |
| Eager to Learn (Bronze) | Complete the Boot Flow Interactive Tutorial |
| Faceoff King (Bronze) | Win 80% of the faceoffs in an Online Versus Play ranked match. |
| Fighting Major (Silver) | Accept and win a fight against a human controlled opponent |
| Gameplay Master (Bronze) | Perform a loose puck deke and score a goal |
| Goal Master (Bronze) | Get 25 goals with your Be A Pro character |
| Goalie Legend (Bronze) | Win 5 matches with your Be A Pro character playing as a goalie |
| Gold Team (Gold) | Be a member of an EA SPORTS Hockey League team that has won a Gold medal |
| Grade A (Gold) | Get an overal A rating in a match with your Be A Prop character |
| Hardcore Superstar (Bronze) | Play and win a match on Hardcore Superstar settings against the CPU |
| It's a Challenge (Bronze) | Challenge and beat another EA Sports Hockey League team |
| It's Not Easy (Bronze) | Beat a NHL team using an AHL team in an Online Versus Play ranked match |
| It's the Playoffs (Bronze) | Complete an Online League playoff match |
| League Champion (Silver) | Win an Online League that has at least 4 members |
| Line Juggler (Bronze) | Do five manual line changes in one match |
| Look No Goalie (Silver) | Pull your goalie and score a goal against the CPU or an online opponent in a ranked match |
| New Beginnings (Bronze) | Complete a match using NHL 94 Control settings |
| No Icing (Silver) | Complete an Online Versus ranked match without being called for icing |
| No Offsides (Silver) | Complete an Online Versus Play ranked match without being called for an offside |
| Out of the Box (Bronze) | Complete an Online Versus Play ranked match without getting a penalty |
| Party Animal (Bronze) | Complete an EA SPORTS Hockey League match with 6 human controlled players on your team. |
| Point Leader (Silver) | Get 60 points with your Be A Pro character |
| Pressure Play (Silver) | Keep the pass completion % for CPU or online opponent in ranked match under 40% |
| Raise Your Banner (Platinum) | Acquire all Bronze, Silver, and Gold Trophies |
| Self Sacrifice (Bronze) | Score a goal with an injured player |
| Shootout Master (Bronze) | Score three goals in a row in an Online Shootout ranked match |
| Shootout Shutout (Bronze) | Win an Online Shootout ranked match without being scored on |
| Silver Team (Silver) | Be a member of an EA SPORTS Hockey League team that has won a Silver Medal |
| Star Power (Bronze) | Get the first star in a match with your Be A Pro character |
| Trophy Case (Gold) | Be a member of a team that has won all the EA SPORTS Hockey League team trophies |
| Unlock Gloves (Bronze) | Earn a pair of 2 slot gloves |
| Unlock Skates (Bronze) | Earn a pair of 2 slot skates |
