| Ammand The Corsair | Successfully complete the Pirate Poker sub-mission in the Shipwreck City level. |
| Black Bart | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Maelstrom level. |
| Bootstrap Bill Turner | Successfully complete the Defeat Enemies sub-mission in the Prison Fortress level. |
| Cannon Arm | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Pearl vs. Kraken level. |
| Capitain Barbossa | Successfully complete the Shipwreck City level. |
| Capitain Chevalle | Successfully complete the Port Royal level. |
| Captain Elizabeth Swann | Successfully complete the Combo Challenge in the Davy Jones Locker level. |
| Captain Jack Sparrow | Successfully complete the Prison Fortress level. |
| Captain Sao Feng | Successfully complete the Singapore level. |
| Captain Teauge | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Prison Fortress level. |
| Cotton | Successfully complete the Rescue sub-mission in the Isla de Pelegostos level. |
| Davy Jones | Successfully complete Pearl vs. Dutchman level. |
| Elizabeth Swann | Successfully complete Tortuga level. |
| Gentlemen Jocard | Successfully complete the Davy Jones Locker level. |
| Gibbs | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Port Royal level. |
| Governor Swann | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Pearl vs. Dutchman level. |
| James Norrington | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Tortuga level. |
| Lian | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Singapore level. |
| Lord Cuttler Beckett | Successfully complete the Maelstrom level. |
| Mercer | Successfully complete the Hit-Combo sub-mission in the Singapore level. |
| Mistress Ching | Successfully complete the Jackanism in the Tortuga level. |
| Mordillah | Successfully complete the Combo Challenge in the Prison Fortress level. |
| Pintel | Successfully complete the Isla Cruces level. |
| Ragetti | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Isla Cruces level. |
| Sri Sumba Jee | Successfully complete the Combat Challenge in the Shipwreck City level. |
| Tai Huang | Successfully complete the Sea Battle level. |
| Tia Dalma | Successfully complete the Missing Person sub-mission in the Port Royal level. |
| Villanueva | Successfully complete the Combo Challenge in the Tortuga level. |
| Will Turner | Successfully complete the Isla de Pelegostos level. |
