| Brothers of Destruction entrance | In Undertaker's RTW make Finley bleed on week 8 |
| Evolution Theme Song, Entrance video, And Trio entrance | HHH RTW: Make sure Orton wins at No way out, And go on to beat him and shawn at wrestlemania |
| Gauntlet Match | During Cena's RTW defeat Mr. Kennedy in under 2.5 minutes on week 12 |
| Hornswoggle as non-playable manager | On the second week of Undertaker's RTW, defeat Finley in less time than it took you to beat Santino |
| Masked Man | Beat Road to Wrestlemania with Chris Jericho. |
| Santino Zombie | When you get the choice in, Undertaker's RTW, face for the lader match Santino. Then beat him, win next week, then lose to Rey Mysterio the next week |
| Snitsky | In Cena's RTW, make MVP bleed on week 11 |
| Special WrestleMania Jeep Entrance for CAE | Complete Cena's RTW |
| The Boogeyman | Beat Road to Wrestlemania with The Undertaker. |
| Tony | Unlock "Tony" by going through John Cenas Road to Wrestlemania. |
| UNLOCK CAS moveset #3 | Whilst doing HHH RTW near the start |
| UNLOCK CM Punk Alt. Attire | Whilst doing CM Punk's RTW - In the second week, put Jeff Hardy through a table. |
| UNLOCK DX Alt. Attire | Whilst doing HHH RTW - In special ref match you play as referee, make sure Shawn Michael's is victorious and then go on to defeat him at WrestleMania. |
| UNLOCK DX Entrance | Whilst doing HHH RTW - Pedigree Randy Orton 3 time's to unlock |
| UNLOCK Jillian Hall | Whilst doing HHH RTW - Win Tag Match 3rd week of Feb |
| UNLOCK Layla | Whilst doing CM Punk's RTW - Defeat Big Daddy V at No way out, in 2 and a half minutes. |
| UNLOCK Locker Room | Whilst doing CM Punk's RTW - Pin John Morrison in an triple threat in March to unlock a new Backstage Brawl |
| UNLOCK Ric Flair | Whilst doing HHH RTW - In special ref match you play as referee, make sure Orton is victorious |
| UNLOCK Tazz | Whilst doing CM Punk's RTW - Complete CM Punk's Road To WrestleMania |
| UNLOCK Tribute to the Troops Arena | Whilst doing John Cena's RTW - Make MVP submit at the Tribute to the Troops arena. |
| UNLOCK Zack Ryder & Curt Hawkins | During the Mysterio/Batista RTW spear edge twice |
| WCW Brand and Title Belt | Complete the challenge for week two, while on Chris Jericho's Road to Wrestlemania story. |
| Zombie Finlay Model | Help Mysterio beat Zombie finlay in Taker's RTW |
