| 5150 (20) | Beat LAX in Story mode (Chapter 4). |
| A Heavyweight Price (35) | Win your first Heavyweight match in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
| Best of the Best (100) | Achieve TNA Champion status on any Leaderboard. |
| Climbing the Ladder (15) | Win two Tag Team matches in Story mode (Chapter 4). |
| Detroit's Finest (25) | Win a Tag Team match using Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin. |
| Don't Fire Eric (20) | Defeat Robert Roode with Eric Young |
| End of a streak (35) | Defeat Samoa Joe with Kurt angle |
| He's Not Phenomenal (25) | Defeat AJ Styles in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
| He's on Fire!! (20) | Create an all flame clothing theme. |
| Highspot Risktaker (40) | Perform 50 aerial moves successfully. |
| It's About No Limits (20) | Win three X Division matches in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
| It's Damn Real! (75) | Defeat Kurt Angle in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
| Jobber Nation (0) | Lose 5 matches on Xbox LIVE in one sitting. |
| King of the Gauntlet (10) | Win the Gauntlet Match in Story mode (Chapter 2). |
| Lucha Libre! (10) | Win the Mexican Gauntlet Match in Story mode (Chapter 1). |
| Mid-Card Contender (25) | Win 25 matches in any mode. |
| On Top of the World (5) | Create a player in Story mode (Chapter 1). |
| Planet Jarrett (20) | Play against a real life TNA wrestler or someone who has. |
| Return of The Icon (5) | Play as Sting. |
| Send'em Home Happy (15) | Perform a signature move to excite the crowd |
| Shark in the Water (50) | Defeat every wrestler on the roster with Shark Boy. |
| Start Your Own Streak (55) | Defeat Samoa Joe in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
| The Bigger They Are... (45) | Defeat Kevin Nash in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
| The New King of TNA (100) | Defeat Jeff Jarrett in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
| This Is Awesome! (30) | Become the X Division Champion in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
| Underdog Wins (30) | Defeat someone of TNA Champion status on any Leaderboard. |
| Welcome to America (10) | Defeat James Storm in Story mode (Chapter 2). |
| Welcome to TNA! (15) | Defeat Robert Roode in Story mode (Chapter 3). |
| World Wide Wrestler (25) | Play 25 ranked matches on Xbox LIVE |
| X Marks the Spot (15) | Win an Ultimate X match. |
