| 5 Hall of Famers (100) | In Career mode, induct 5 Superstars to the Hall of Fame. |
| 5 Stars (60) | In Career mode, Obtain a 5-Star match rating. |
| A brawl to end them all (30) | Win in both a Locker Room Brawl and Backstage Brawl. |
| A year in the life (100) | Complete 1 year of Career Mode playing each match. |
| Bonus Collector (150) | Obtain all bonuses in Road to WrestleMania mode. |
| Cena Story (20) | Complete Cena's story in Road to WrestleMania mode. |
| Chris Jericho Story (20) | Complete Chris Jericho's story in Road to WrestleMania mode. |
| Congrats are in order (10) | Win an Exhibition match. |
| Create A Finisher (10) | Defeat an opponent using a Created Finisher in a match. |
| Gold Rush (60) | In Career mode, win every WWE Championship at least once. |
| Lights,Camera,Action! (30) | Create at least 1 original WWE highlight reel. |
| Mysterio & Batista Story (40) | Complete Mysterio & Batista's story in Road to WrestleMania mode using both Superstars. |
| Smokin' (20) | Defeat Kane in an Inferno Match. |
| Triple H Story (40) | Complete Triple H's DX and Evolution route in Road to WrestleMania mode. |
| Undertaker Story (20) | Complete Undertaker's story in Road to WrestleMania mode. |
| Unstoppable (60) | Use a created Superstar and obtain 6 abilities in Career Mode. |
